In recent years, with the pace of industrial development and transfer worldwide, many well-known companies have begun to shift to places with cheaper labor costs. Southeast Asia has become a hot spot in the market for a time. However, recently, it was rumored that Tesla, a world-renowned automotive giant, had abandoned its plan to build a factory in Southeast Asia. What is Tesla's purpose in doing so? How should we analyze it?

I. Did Tesla Abandon Its Plan to Build a Factory in Southeast Asia?

According to the 21st Century Business Herald, in the race to compete for emerging markets, Tesla chose to back down in the face of difficulties.

According to Thai sources, Tesla has canceled plans to build an electric vehicle factory in Southeast Asia. The team originally sent to Thailand to establish the factory has been withdrawn, and currently, only the construction of charging infrastructure in the local area is being considered. In addition to China, the United States, and Germany, Tesla will not build new Gigafactories in Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia, or anywhere else.

Soon, this information was confirmed by high-level officials in Malaysia. Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim responded that Tesla's decision to postpone its expansion plans in Malaysia was not due to Malaysia's poor performance but rather due to the fierce competition between Tesla and Chinese automakers. Zairil Khir Johari, Malaysia's Minister of Investment, Trade, and Industry, also stated that Tesla halted its factory construction plans because it had lost market orders and struggled to compete with Chinese automakers. However, Tesla's withdrawal would not have a substantial impact on Malaysia.

According to market research firm Counterpoint Research, the total sales of electric vehicles in the Southeast Asian market surged 894% year-on-year in the second quarter of 2023, the highest growth rate globally. In the first quarter of this year, while fuel vehicle sales in Southeast Asia declined by 7%, electric vehicle sales doubled compared to the same period last year. With such impressive growth rates, Tesla naturally coveted the Southeast Asian emerging market.

According to the Global Times, Tesla currently has four vehicle assembly plants worldwide, located in Shanghai, China; Berlin, Germany; Austin, Texas, USA; and Fremont, California, USA. In August 2022, Elon Musk announced his desire to establish 10 to 12 “Gigafactories” globally. Malaysia, Thailand, and Indonesia have all actively sought Tesla's investment.

“Southeast Asia had high hopes for Tesla to establish a ‘Gigafactory’ locally, as the billions of dollars in investment would significantly boost local manufacturing and electric vehicle development,” reported the South China Morning Post. Before Tesla's strategic shift, both Thai Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha and Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim had met with Elon Musk. Last year, Musk expressed interest in the Malaysian market and intended to bring Tesla and other businesses to the country. To attract Tesla, Malaysia abandoned its long-standing joint venture policy, allowing Tesla to enter the market independently.

Meanwhile, Thailand has also sought to attract Tesla investments. In December last year, Thai Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha personally accompanied Tesla executives on a tour of three industrial zones in Thailand, expressing confidence that Tesla would invest in Thailand's entire electric vehicle supply chain, creating numerous job opportunities.

II. What is Tesla's Purpose in Abandoning Its Southeast Asia Plans?

In recent years, it has become common for well-known manufacturing companies to shift production to Southeast Asia in search of lower costs and higher profits. However, Tesla is bucking this trend. What is going on here?

First, industrial transfer under economic globalization is the norm in the current market. In the wave of economic globalization, multinational corporations have commonly relocated their production lines to emerging markets. As companies continue to grow and expand, labor costs and production factor prices in their original production locations gradually increase, compressing their profit margins. To reduce production costs and enhance competitiveness, industrial transfer has become a necessary choice for many companies. Southeast Asia, with its low labor costs and abundant natural resources, has become a popular destination for industrial transfer.

From an economic development perspective, industrial transfer is an inevitable trend. As a country or region's economy develops, labor costs, land prices, and other production factor prices inevitably rise. To maintain competitiveness, companies need to find lower-cost production locations. Southeast Asia, with its relatively low labor costs, is attractive to labor-intensive industries. Additionally, the region is rich in natural resources such as oil, natural gas, and rubber, facilitating production. As labor costs rise in regions like China, transferring to Southeast Asia seems a natural choice to reduce costs.

Second, the specific circumstances of the Southeast Asian market are the reason for Tesla's abandonment. When closely examining various materials on Southeast Asian manufacturing, it becomes clear that the region is not the promised land many envision. Applying this context to Tesla, it becomes apparent that the region may not be a good fit:

First, purchasing power in Southeast Asia is limited, yet competition is intense. While the Southeast Asian market presents many opportunities, local purchasing power has yet to catch up. The region's economic development level is relatively low, with most countries having low per capita incomes, limiting consumers' ability to purchase high-end electric vehicles. As a high-end electric vehicle manufacturer, Tesla's products are relatively expensive, potentially restricting sales in the Southeast Asian market.

Furthermore, competition in the Southeast Asian market has become intense. In the race to transition to new energy sources, Chinese automakers have secured a leading position in Southeast Asia. According to a Counterpoint Research report, Chinese brands, led by BYD, accounted for over 70% of electric vehicle sales in Southeast Asia in the first quarter of this year. Tesla faces fierce competition in the region due to the strong performance of Chinese automakers. In this context, Tesla's cautious approach to expanding in Southeast Asia is understandable.

Second, Southeast Asia's industrial base and manufacturing capabilities are not as robust. While labor costs in Southeast Asia are low, the educational level of the local workforce is uneven, which may affect production efficiency and product quality. As a high-tech company, Tesla demands high-quality labor. In Southeast Asia, it may be challenging to find sufficient skilled labor to meet production needs.

Moreover, Southeast Asia's industrial base has shortcomings. While the region has a foundation in traditional manufacturing sectors, its industrial base in high-tech areas like new energy vehicles is relatively weak. Establishing a factory in Southeast Asia would require Tesla to invest heavily in building and improving the local industrial infrastructure, posing a significant challenge for the company.

Third, the business environment in Southeast Asia is not entirely stable. Uncertainty in the business environment is another significant reason for Tesla's decision to abandon its Southeast Asia plans. The political, economic, and social environments in Southeast Asia are relatively unstable, with frequent policy changes and uncertainties. This can pose significant risks to corporate investments and production. For example, changes in tax and land policies in some Southeast Asian countries can easily affect corporate costs and profits. Additionally, infrastructure development in some countries lags behind, with issues related to transportation and energy directly impacting corporate operations. Due to policy uncertainties, the attractiveness of the Southeast Asian market for manufacturing companies seeking long-term stability has diminished.

Third, Tesla's abandonment of its Southeast Asia plans does not mean abandoning the market. For Tesla, choosing to temporarily abandon its Southeast Asia layout in its strategic adjustment does not signify a complete retreat or abandonment of the region. Rather, it is a well-considered decision. On the one hand, this decision reflects Tesla's extreme caution in manufacturing. Amidst increasing competition in the global electric vehicle market, Tesla needs to ensure maximum benefits and returns from every investment. Therefore, temporarily shelving direct layout in Southeast Asia is a comprehensive consideration based on cost control, supply chain stability, and production efficiency.

On the other hand, Tesla's vast manufacturing base in Shanghai, China, provides a strong foundation and flexibility. This base boasts sufficient production capacity and relies on China's comprehensive industrial system and supply chain network to respond quickly to market demand changes and achieve efficient production. More importantly, as market demand grows, Tesla can easily expand the production capacity of its Shanghai factory to meet demand in a wider range of regions, including Southeast Asia. This flexibility and scalability allow Tesla to maintain its focus on the Southeast Asian market without rushing into large-scale direct investments in the region.

Tesla's globalization strategy is comprehensive and long-term, transcending short-term gains and losses in individual markets. By deeply cultivating key regions like China, Tesla has not only consolidated its market position but also accumulated valuable international operational experience. This experience is equally valuable for Tesla's potential future entry into the Southeast Asian market. Therefore, even if Tesla has not directly established a presence in the Southeast Asian market for now, it remains fully capable of entering the region in a more mature and stable manner in the future.

Thus, we can conclude that Tesla's decision to temporarily abandon its direct layout in Southeast Asia is based on a profound understanding of global electric vehicle market trends and precise control over its resource allocation. Choosing to produce in markets where it has greater control is undoubtedly Elon Musk's true choice.

Quote of the Day

Don't dwell too long on things that make you uncomfortable. If you do, you'll end up hurting, feeling exhausted, and breaking your heart. In reality, in the end, you're not struggling with the situation; you're struggling with yourself.